diff --git a/src/mail/mail_reader.py b/src/mail/mail_reader.py
index 3756619..a8ca936 100755
--- a/src/mail/mail_reader.py
+++ b/src/mail/mail_reader.py
@@ -181,10 +181,7 @@ class MailReader():
         return mail_messages
 
 
-def need_to_valid_url(url: str, successful_items):
-    # return True
-    # if len(successful_items) == 0:
-    #     return False
+def need_to_valid_url(url: str, email, successful_items):
     print("url is :" + url)
     parts = url.split('/')
     id = parts[5]
@@ -198,6 +195,9 @@ def need_to_valid_url(url: str, successful_items):
                     if item.url_validated is not None:
                         return item, not item.url_validated
                     return item, True
+        for item in successful_items:
+            if item.mail == email:
+                return item, True
         return None, True
     else:
         print("id not valid:{}".format(id))
@@ -262,7 +262,7 @@ def read_mails():
                 match = re.search(VALIDATION_URL_REGEX, mail.body)
                 if match:
                     url = match.group(0)
-                    _item, is_need_to = need_to_valid_url(url, _refreshed_successful_items)
+                    _item, is_need_to = need_to_valid_url(url, mail.to_address, _refreshed_successful_items)
                     if is_need_to:
                         MONGO_STORE_MANAGER.save_links_to_validate(url, mail.to_address, _all_contact_list, _item,
                                                                    contact_serial_map_list)
diff --git a/src/mail/mail_reader_all_contacts.py b/src/mail/mail_reader_all_contacts.py
index 78ed30b..c0a17da 100755
--- a/src/mail/mail_reader_all_contacts.py
+++ b/src/mail/mail_reader_all_contacts.py
@@ -293,7 +293,7 @@ def read_all_mails(contact_to_book_list=None):
                     #     url = "https://rendezvousparis.hermes.com/" + url_to_validate.replace("3D", "")
                     # else:
                     url = match.group(0)
-                    _item, is_need_to = need_to_valid_url(url, _refreshed_successful_items)
+                    _item, is_need_to = need_to_valid_url(url, mail.to_address, _refreshed_successful_items)
                     if is_need_to:
                         print("need to validate url: " + url)
                         MONGO_STORE_MANAGER.save_links_to_validate(url, mail.to_address,